So I've been pondering....

Here you can talk about anything that isn't covered by the other categories.
Post Reply
Dr_Liszt

So I've been pondering....

Post by Dr_Liszt »

Does democracy really exist?

I've complained in the past that Guatemala and also the U.S* voting is pointless because our systems are ruled by corporations and monopolies that finance and practically set the politics. So what you really have is an illusion of choice. Yes you do vote, but who really rules? The people who finance the party say what's in and out of the party. That's the reality of the situation. When I hear people complaining "Ohh Cuba only has one party!! That's dictatorship!!!" I go like this: [roll] Cubans might only choose from one party, we get to choose from diverse parties that in the end are essentially one. We have an illusion of freedom but we are not free. What Anita Sarkeesian said on the video I posted.

So I wonder if other countries are the same. Especially Europe or Australia, if the population actually had a say on what goes on in their countries politic-wise. And then I found this, Australian Aamer Rahman talking about the illusion of choice as a mean to control the population:



So...... are we all sheep to the corporations now? Is that what the world is?

** EDIT: Also to anyone saying "OOOOOOH LISZT WHY YOU COMPLAIN BOUT MURICA! YOU DON'T LIVE HERE!!!" Well I guess when said country has been influencing the other since the Mexican separation, I've earned my right to complain about what influences/exploits/oppresses me.
thesalmonofdoubt
Global Moderator
Posts: 477
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 11:34 pm

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by thesalmonofdoubt »

wonder if other countries are the same. Especially Europe or Australia, if the population actually had a say on what goes on in their countries politic-wise. And then I found this, Australian Aamer Rahman talking about the illusion of choice as a mean to control the population
Yeah - well I agree and disagree with the chap above. Essentially is a depressing case of different bucket, same shit when you vote. Economically, both parties, right and left have modified versions of a centralist view on how to manage the country. Social issues usually manifest quite differently between the two parties, for example, Labour would never introduce a "work for the dole" scheme, but its one of the first things that the amusingly confusingly titled "Liberals" tried to do as soon as they were voted in.

I don't think corporations have quite as influential a role on policy here as they do in the states past, liberals are more likely to pander to corporate sensibilities given, ideologically, that's how they see wealth creation happening - while Labour tends to be more about getting their pound of flesh out of corporations in order to pay for social welfare programs.

Essentially tho, they are much of a muchness altho I think its as much a symptom of pragmatism as it is anything else. In a two party system, legislation only gets passed if it passes thru the house of commons - so, any change requires that both houses agree to the change with swing voters being likely - even expected from both houses.. Its a kinda checks and balances system that ensures there are no wild policy shifts as far as possible which obviously promotes a stasis of policy.

The media is probably the most influential player in the mix. Some papers have an obvious political bias towards one party or another so that who ever has the biggest readership swings favour in one direction or another.

Having said that - one good thing that we do is televise political debate in a thing called "Question time" .. every week, parliamentary sittings are aired - live with no editing so the public can see the debate that goes on behind policy making.. It's heated and hardly shows a unified front on a range of issues from social,. international and economic so, looking at these debates you can see that both houses have radically different views on the variety of ways to handle certain issues but - the checks and balances thing keeps the results of these debates to a more moderately static middle ground compromise.

Naturally - if one party has a vast majority in both houses - change happens quickly and the real differences in policy usually come thru - but that doesn't happen often on account of how we elect the senate and the commons on different frequencies so that any public sentiment can be expressed by way of the electoral process

TL/DR - essentially, yes, there is an illusion of choice but there isn't a simple reason for this - at least here in Oz.
phe_de
Ultra Poster
Posts: 545
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2015 10:58 am
Location: Germany

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by phe_de »

Switzerland.
Common sense is another word for prejudice.
Dr_Liszt

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Dr_Liszt »

phe_de wrote:Switzerland.
Ughhh... [roll] Fucking Switzerland. [roll] What about fucking Switzerland?
User avatar
Cassius Clay
Ultimate Poster
Posts: 2419
Joined: Sun Jan 04, 2015 8:03 pm

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Cassius Clay »

I almost went to boarding school in Switzerland.

I woulda gotten all the bitches. [none]
Image
Dr_Liszt

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Dr_Liszt »

Switzerland is shit, damn, imperialist, dirty country. It's A DIRTY fucking country.
User avatar
Cassius Clay
Ultimate Poster
Posts: 2419
Joined: Sun Jan 04, 2015 8:03 pm

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Cassius Clay »

But I hear there are beautiful women there. [none]
Image
Dr_Liszt

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Dr_Liszt »

I'm still going to bomb the shit out of it. [none]
User avatar
Cassius Clay
Ultimate Poster
Posts: 2419
Joined: Sun Jan 04, 2015 8:03 pm

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Cassius Clay »

Nooooooo! Think of the sexy women(forget the children). [sad2]
Image
phe_de
Ultra Poster
Posts: 545
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2015 10:58 am
Location: Germany

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by phe_de »

Switzerland has a direct democracy. And it works.
Common sense is another word for prejudice.
Dr_Liszt

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Dr_Liszt »

Cassius Clay wrote:Nooooooo! Think of the sexy women(forget the children). [sad2]
There will be no mercy when the revolution comes!!!
Dr_Liszt

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Dr_Liszt »

phe_de wrote:Switzerland has a direct democracy. And it works.
I will look into it when I'm feeling better. It might work. I heard anarchy worked in Belgium too.
Blade Azaezel
Ultra Poster
Posts: 877
Joined: Wed Feb 25, 2015 12:18 am

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Blade Azaezel »

Democracy doesn't work because the ignorant, unwashed masses get an equal vote and they're all idiots.
User avatar
OpiateOfTheMasses
Global Moderator
Posts: 520
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 11:14 pm
Location: A little island somewhere

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by OpiateOfTheMasses »

Democracy is a crap solution, but its the least crap solution we've got.

The biggest problem with it aren't the politicians, it's the voters. The vast majority of them are stupid, completely self-centred, lazy and short-termist, so those that can even be bothered to vote end up electing politicians that tell them what they want to hear in easily digestible sound bites.
You can't make everyone happy. You are not pizza.
Derived Absurdity
Ultimate Poster
Posts: 2811
Joined: Sun Jan 04, 2015 5:07 am

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Derived Absurdity »

OpiateOfTheMasses wrote:The biggest problem with it aren't the politicians, it's the voters. The vast majority of them are stupid, completely self-centred, lazy and short-termist
Except for us, of course.
User avatar
OpiateOfTheMasses
Global Moderator
Posts: 520
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 11:14 pm
Location: A little island somewhere

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by OpiateOfTheMasses »

Yeah... of course except for us... [eyes]
You can't make everyone happy. You are not pizza.
Unvoiced_Apollo
Ultimate Poster
Posts: 1794
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2015 5:11 pm

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Unvoiced_Apollo »

OpiateOfTheMasses wrote:Democracy is a crap solution, but its the least crap solution we've got.

The biggest problem with it aren't the politicians, it's the voters. The vast majority of them are stupid, completely self-centred, lazy and short-termist, so those that can even be bothered to vote end up electing politicians that tell them what they want to hear in easily digestible sound bites.

Why do you think I voted for myself in the last election?
Dr_Liszt

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Dr_Liszt »

Unvoiced_Apollo wrote:
OpiateOfTheMasses wrote:Democracy is a crap solution, but its the least crap solution we've got.

The biggest problem with it aren't the politicians, it's the voters. The vast majority of them are stupid, completely self-centred, lazy and short-termist, so those that can even be bothered to vote end up electing politicians that tell them what they want to hear in easily digestible sound bites.

Why do you think I voted for myself in the last election?
Best. Idea. Ever.

Although I'm not sure how I would be as a president. I'd rather be a dictator or an emperor or something. EMPRESS... I mean Empress. [none]
User avatar
CashRules
Ultimate Poster
Posts: 2013
Joined: Fri Jan 02, 2015 12:08 am
Location: The Barn

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by CashRules »

The solution is to stop pondering. Pondering never helped anyone.
__
You can't hang a man for killing a woman who's trying to steal his horse.
Dr_Liszt

Re: So I've been pondering....

Post by Dr_Liszt »

What makes you think that? I will ponder the hell out of the system.

Also, I read the J-man's house of commons thing. It's a nice idea. I'll learn about gimme-your-dirty-money-Switzerland tomorrow.
Post Reply