Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
- Cinemachinery
- Super Poster
- Posts: 113
- Joined: Tue Jan 06, 2015 6:03 pm
Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
A friend of mine recently posted on Facebook about Kanye West getting an honorary doctorate from Chicago's Art Institute. He captioned it with "*huge eye roll* Is the Art Institute desperate for PR? What a joke."
My response was "The guy is an unmitigated douche and huge ego, yes, but he's talented and pushes the envelope. Pollock was a drunk who threatened his wife and pissed on his own art, but no one questions his status in the lexicon of artists of various stripes."
There ensued this whole exchange which boiled down to:
Him: I can't look past personal flaws that easily, they comment on the art
Me: The art exists in a vacuum.
He then asked if I wanted my daughter patterning herself after the way he acts (good point, role models and all) and my counterpoint was that I would be raising my daughter to not confuse the artist with the art and, by way of example, I pointed out that she loved Dr. Suess and I wouldn't fault her for it, though the man was racist as hell and supported the dehumanization and internment of Japanese Americans during WW2.
I further pointed out that I enjoy John Lennon but I don't beat or cheat on my wife, I like Connery as 007 but I don't slap women about, I like Dali but I don't host weekly orgies.
What say ye? Is the art lesser for the artist's flaws?
My response was "The guy is an unmitigated douche and huge ego, yes, but he's talented and pushes the envelope. Pollock was a drunk who threatened his wife and pissed on his own art, but no one questions his status in the lexicon of artists of various stripes."
There ensued this whole exchange which boiled down to:
Him: I can't look past personal flaws that easily, they comment on the art
Me: The art exists in a vacuum.
He then asked if I wanted my daughter patterning herself after the way he acts (good point, role models and all) and my counterpoint was that I would be raising my daughter to not confuse the artist with the art and, by way of example, I pointed out that she loved Dr. Suess and I wouldn't fault her for it, though the man was racist as hell and supported the dehumanization and internment of Japanese Americans during WW2.
I further pointed out that I enjoy John Lennon but I don't beat or cheat on my wife, I like Connery as 007 but I don't slap women about, I like Dali but I don't host weekly orgies.
What say ye? Is the art lesser for the artist's flaws?
Even I find my avatar disturbing.
-
- Ultra Poster
- Posts: 877
- Joined: Wed Feb 25, 2015 12:18 am
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
The art is lessened slightly, in my opinion, by the artist's unpleasantries. I find it difficult to enjoy the Lethal Weapon films, for example, because Gibson is a colossal arsehole. Still, ignorance is bliss.
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
I have a real difficulty in separating the art from the artist because I don't believe that the art does exist in a vacuum - anything that comes from your mind is coming from, to some extent, your values, your processes, your social biases and you can't, IMO, criticise the end product without criticising the artist.
Buuuuut, despite all that, I agree with you and not your friend, in that you cannot excoriate Kanye for being a douche without taking huge swathes of the artistic world to task as well because artists are generally shitbags #notallartists
Buuuuut, despite all that, I agree with you and not your friend, in that you cannot excoriate Kanye for being a douche without taking huge swathes of the artistic world to task as well because artists are generally shitbags #notallartists
WORDS IN THE HEART CANNOT BE TAKEN
-
- Ultra Poster
- Posts: 877
- Joined: Wed Feb 25, 2015 12:18 am
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
People just don't like him because he's black and successful although, actually, that may have a hint of truth to it. Crackers be bitter, yo.
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
Like, we can all agree that Chris Brown is a garbage person for beating up Rihanna but there are a shit ton of white artists who've been given a pass for violence. Roman Polanksi raped a child and a they let him win an Oscar. Crackers *are* bitter.
WORDS IN THE HEART CANNOT BE TAKEN
-
- Ultra Poster
- Posts: 877
- Joined: Wed Feb 25, 2015 12:18 am
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
I'm an equal opportunities hater. People, what a bunch of bastards...insert gif of Roy from IT Crowd that I can't find cos I'm on my phone.
-
- Ultra Poster
- Posts: 877
- Joined: Wed Feb 25, 2015 12:18 am
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
3good 5me, broseph
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
I'm in agreement with your side, mostly. We'd all be hard-pressed to locate racist undertones in Suess books. Most great artists and writers (especially pre-20th century) have been racists, sexists, whatever the norm was for the day. I mean, Shakespeare was pretty anti-Semite, but so was everyone. Doesn't make it OK, but no one in their right mind is going to invalidate Shakespeare. Ya know. Dickens, Poe, Dostoyevsky, Dumas, Coleridge...all typically considered among the best writers ever, were all historically quite racist. Kanye's a massive douchenozzle, but that should not take away from his musical ability. (Personally, I think he's a terrible rapper so far as rappers go, but he is a top-notch producer, so if his douchebaggery comes through in his lyrics [and it does], I still respect him as an artist in the production department.)
The agonies which are have their origin in the ecstasies which might have been.
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
I struggle to separate the art from the person. I mean, I don't think I'll ever listen to a Lost Prophets song again(I listened when I was a teenager, not so much in recent years, but every now and then a song would come on and I'd like it) since finding out about Ian Watkins.
- Cinemachinery
- Super Poster
- Posts: 113
- Joined: Tue Jan 06, 2015 6:03 pm
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
I had to look up who that was and WHOA PAEDOPHILE.
Even I find my avatar disturbing.
-
- Ultra Poster
- Posts: 877
- Joined: Wed Feb 25, 2015 12:18 am
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
Ian Watkins totally fucked over the rest of the Lost Prophets. I occasionally listen to their songs, but it isn't the same anymore.
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
I can't separate them either, however, if a "ahole" artist receives something that has to do with art, then that's ok by me. If he was being given a doctorate in something that had nothing to do with his art that would be something else.
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
If you look up the court documents I think that are floating around the internet, it's very hard reading.Cinemachinery wrote:I had to look up who that was and WHOA PAEDOPHILE.
- Cinemachinery
- Super Poster
- Posts: 113
- Joined: Tue Jan 06, 2015 6:03 pm
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
As the father of a two year old, I think I have enough rage and worry in my life, so no, I won't do that.
Even I find my avatar disturbing.
- Ptolemy_Banana
- Super Poster
- Posts: 359
- Joined: Tue Jan 06, 2015 1:03 pm
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
I can separate the art from the artist. I'm not giving up my Jim'll Fix It box-sets for anybody.
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
I separate the art and the artist. Gesualdo was a murderer, but he wrote interesting music. And it wasn't the music that committed the murders.Cinemachinery wrote:What say ye? Is the art lesser for the artist's flaws?
But anyway: Taylor Swift > Kanye West.
Common sense is another word for prejudice.
-
- Ultimate Poster
- Posts: 1289
- Joined: Fri Jan 02, 2015 3:20 am
Re: Kanye and "Unlikable" artists
I generally don't give a shit what artists/celebrities do in their personal lives. I haven't heard a Kanye West song I like, but I've heard a couple that are laughably bad, and that has nothing to do with his personality.